A Prenup to Protect Inheritance: The Family Conversation

A Prenup to Protect an Inheritance: How Families Raise It Without Breaking the Engagement

Editorial note: This essay is about family conversations, not legal drafting. Faith & Wealth is not a law firm. Premarital agreements are governed by state law, which differs from state to state; we quote one state’s statute only as an example. Anyone considering a prenuptial agreement, and anyone asked to sign one, should work with a family-law attorney licensed in their state, and each party should have their own. See our editorial disclosure.

The engagement is announced, the families are delighted, and somewhere in the background a parent who has spent forty years building a business is losing sleep. They like the person their daughter is marrying. They also know that their estate plan assumes the business, the land, or the family trust will stay in the family line. They want to suggest a prenup to protect inheritance, and they have no idea how to raise it without sounding as if they expect the marriage to fail. This essay is for that parent, and for the heir caught between a family and a fiancé.

The conversation between the couple themselves is a different subject, which we cover in Marriage, Money, and Meaning. Here the focus is the three-way conversation: parents, heir, and partner.

The conversation parents want and cannot quite start

Parents in this position usually want three things at once. They want the family’s assets to pass down the family line as they intend. They want their child’s marriage to succeed. And they want the person marrying in to feel welcomed, not suspected. Those goals are not in conflict, but the way the subject is raised can make them feel as if they are.

The most common mistake is timing. A request that arrives a few weeks before the wedding, from a parent, delivered through the heir, sounds like an ultimatum. The same idea, raised early, framed as a family practice rather than a judgment on one person, and handled with care for the partner’s interests, can feel like what it usually is: a family trying to keep its promises to the next generation.

What a prenup can address, in one state’s words

Every state sets its own rules, and readers should not assume that what is true in one state applies in theirs. But a single example shows the kind of ground these agreements can cover. California, which places its rules in a chapter titled the Uniform Premarital Agreement Act, lists what a premarital agreement may cover, including “the disposition of property upon separation, marital dissolution, death, or the occurrence or nonoccurrence of any other event” and “the making of a will, trust, or other arrangement to carry out the provisions of the agreement.” It also states that “the right of a child to support may not be adversely affected by a premarital agreement.”

That list explains why families with significant wealth think about these agreements. A prenup can, in many states, set out how property each person brings or later inherits will be treated. Whether a particular clause will hold, and how it interacts with a family trust or business agreement, is precisely the work of a family-law attorney. The family’s job is different: to decide what it hopes to protect, and why, before anyone drafts anything.

Prenups are no longer unusual

Parents who grew up when prenups were associated with celebrity divorces may be surprised by how ordinary they have become, especially among younger couples. A Harris Poll survey conducted for Axios in September 2023 found that 50% of U.S. adults at least somewhat supported the use of prenups, up from 42% in Harris’s survey the year before, although only about 1 in 5 married couples had one. Among engaged or ever-married respondents, 41% of Gen Z and 47% of millennials said they had entered a prenup (Axios).

Those figures matter for the conversation. The heir and the partner may well be more comfortable with the idea than the parents expect. In many engagements today, the question is not whether a prenup is acceptable but whose idea it is and how it is presented.

A prenup is one tool among several

Families sometimes treat a prenup as the only way to keep an inheritance in the family line. It is not. How an inheritance is held, for example whether assets pass outright or remain in a trust, and how a family business’s ownership agreements are written, can matter as much as anything the couple signs. Some families find that careful estate planning reduces the pressure on the engagement conversation, because the protections already exist in documents the heir did not have to negotiate with their partner.

We do not recommend any structure. How these tools interact varies by state and by family, and an estate attorney and a family-law attorney should look at them together. The point for families is simply that a prenup to protect inheritance is one option among several, and that the conversation is easier when it is not carrying the whole weight.

How parents can raise a prenup to protect inheritance

The plan below is a three-party conversation plan for parents, heir, and partner. It is drawn from the patterns families and advisers describe, not from a study, and every family will adapt it.

When Who talks What they say What to avoid
Long before any engagement Parents with all their children That the family expects every child to consider a prenup when they marry, and why: the business, the land, the promises made to the next generation. Raising it for the first time about one specific partner.
When the relationship becomes serious Heir with partner The family’s practice, in the heir’s own words, as something the couple will decide together. Presenting it as the parents’ demand.
Early in the engagement Parents with the couple What the family hopes to protect and what it does not: the partner is welcome, the family line’s assets are held in trust for the next generation. Discussing figures or clauses; that belongs with the lawyers.
Months before the wedding Each partner with their own attorney Full financial disclosure, negotiation, and drafting, with time to read and reconsider. Last-minute signing, or one lawyer for both.

The first row does most of the work. When a family has said for years that every child will be asked to consider a prenup, the request is no longer about one partner. It becomes a family rule, like the ones families write into a family constitution. Families that have already discussed how inheritance will work with their adult children usually find this conversation much easier, because the heir already understands what is being protected and why.

Parents also need to accept a limit. The heir and the partner are the ones signing. Parents can explain the family’s hopes and, in many cases, make their own estate plans accordingly. They cannot, and should not try to, negotiate the couple’s agreement for them.

If you are the heir in the middle

The heir often carries the heaviest load: loyal to parents who built something, and in love with someone who did not ask to be examined. A few principles help. Own the request rather than passing it along; if you agree a prenup to protect inheritance makes sense, say so in your own words, and if you do not, tell your parents before anyone speaks to your partner. Separate what your parents want from what you and your partner decide; they may shape their own estate plans, but the agreement is yours. And treat the conversation as the first of many about money in your marriage, not the only one.

Heirs who have been included in family conversations for years usually find this part easier, because they can explain the family’s reasons from the inside. Heirs who are learning about the family’s wealth for the first time during an engagement are in a far harder position, which is one more argument for starting those conversations early.

Fairness to the person marrying in

A prenup that feels like an ambush rarely protects anyone. It can damage the marriage it was meant to support, and in many states an agreement signed under pressure or without full information is vulnerable. California’s statute again offers a useful example of what fairness looks like in law. In California, a premarital agreement is not enforceable if the party challenging it proves they did not sign voluntarily, or that it was unconscionable when signed and they lacked fair, reasonable and full disclosure of the other party’s property and obligations (and did not waive it in writing or otherwise know). The statute treats an agreement as not voluntary unless, among other conditions, that party was represented by independent counsel or expressly waived counsel in a separate writing after being advised to seek it at least seven calendar days before signing, and, for agreements signed on or after January 1, 2020, had not less than seven calendar days between first seeing the final agreement and signing it (California Family Code §1615).

Other states set different rules, but the values underneath are widely shared, and they are good family practice anywhere: tell the partner the truth about what is being protected, give them their own lawyer, and give them time. A family that treats the person marrying in with that kind of respect is far more likely to keep both its assets and its relationships.

For families of faith, there is a further consideration. A prenup can be presented as an exit plan, or as an act of stewardship: a way of keeping promises made to children and grandchildren while welcoming a new member of the family. The second framing is not a trick. It describes what many families are actually trying to do. Our Marriage & Family Dynamics section collects related essays, including on fairness between siblings, and our pillar essay on the 3-generation wealth problem explains why these conversations shape what lasts.

Frequently asked questions

Can a prenup protect an inheritance?

In many states, a premarital agreement can address how property each spouse brings or later inherits will be treated. California’s statute, for example, allows agreements on the disposition of property upon dissolution or death. Whether a specific clause is enforceable depends on state law and how the agreement was made, so each party should have their own family-law attorney.

Should parents ask their child to get a prenup?

Parents can explain what the family hopes to protect and why, ideally as a family practice raised long before any engagement. The decision and the negotiation belong to the couple and their separate attorneys.

How common are prenups?

A September 2023 Harris Poll survey for Axios found that about 1 in 5 married couples had a prenup, while 41% of engaged or ever-married Gen Z respondents and 47% of millennials said they had entered one.

What makes a prenup fair to the person marrying in?

Full disclosure, independent legal counsel, and enough time to consider the agreement. California, for example, requires at least seven calendar days between first seeing the final agreement and signing it for agreements signed since 2020. Rules differ by state.

Sources

  • California Family Code §1612 and §1615 (Chapter 2, Uniform Premarital Agreement Act). §1612; §1615. Consulted November 16, 2026.
  • Carly Mallenbaum, “America embraces prenups: 50% of adults open to signing,” Axios, September 24, 2023, reporting a Harris Poll survey conducted for Axios. axios.com.


This essay is part of Marriage & Family Dynamics: marriage, sibling conflict, and the character money cannot buy. New to Faith & Wealth? Start here.

Leave a Comment